The Lost Alleys Of Cloth Fair

For this week’s post I am in Cloth Fair, a street just off West Smithfield with a name that goes back to the early days of the Bartholomew Fair held here when the fair was a centre for cloth merchants from across the country.

The street name and buildings indicate that when walking down this street we are following in the footsteps of those who have walked Cloth Fair for centuries, but all is not quiet what it seems along the street as I will show later in the post, but for now, it was tracking down the location of one of my father’s photos that took me to Cloth Fair, and to these buildings which he photographed in 1951:

Cloth Fair

The focus of my father’s photo was the taller of the buildings with the bay windows. These are numbers 41 and 42 Cloth Fair, the oldest residential buildings within the current boundaries of the City of London.

Construction of these buildings started at the end of the 16th century with completion early in the 17th, at a time when the area was within the walled compound of St. Bartholomew’s. They survived the Great Fire of London, and as my father’s photo confirms, they also survived the blitz.

The building on the right, number 40 was occupied by Mitchell, Inman & Co. a wholesale firm in the cloth trade, so even when my father took the photo in 1951 there was still a business specialising in the product after which the street was named. Mitchell, Inman & Co. produced a wide range of cloth based products, and in the London Evening Standard in 1866 they were advertising as “The cheapest house in London for Billiard, Bagatelle, and Card Table cloths.”

My father’s photo was taken from up against the church where, typically for photographing London today, there was building work underway, so my photo is from further along Cloth Fair, but shows the buildings are much the same today.

Cloth Fair

Ian Nairn described the houses as wonderful – “Wonderful not as a specimen of rustic late-seventeenth century architecture, not even as a very pretty building (which it is), but as an embodiment of the old London spirit. Chunky, cantankerous, breaking out all over in oriels and roof lights, unconcerned with academies, fashions or anything else other than shapes to live in. There was a lot of this in London after the fire; this is now almost the only example left.”

The buildings were almost lost early in the 20th century when they were classified as dangerous structures. The architects Paul Paget and John Seely bought the buildings in 1930 and carried out a very sympathetic restoration. They continued living and working together in number 41 and their success enabled them to purchase and restore many other buildings in Cloth Fair.

The following print shows 41 and 42 Cloth Fair in 1851 with shops occupying the ground floor of the building:

Cloth Fair

By 1930, 41 and 42 Cloth Fair had already survived other major changes in Cloth Fair. Up until the start of the 20th century Cloth Fair and the surrounding area included numerous crowded alleys with very unsanitary conditions. The Corporation of London Sanitary Committee condemned many of the buildings in 1914 and their demolition was completed soon after.

The state of Cloth Fair was frequently mentioned in newspapers. Cloth Fair and the Hand and Shears pub were part of the opening and administration of the Bartholomew Fair and the opening of the 1829 fair is recorded in the London Courier and Evening Gazette with “the usual formalities as they are ostentatiously styled, do not go beyond some such ceremony as that of the Lord Mayor and Sheriffs standing in a filthy lane, called Cloth Fair, whilst a Marshalman or Herald miserably reads a proclamation, enjoining such as frequent the fair to abstain from all proprieties.”

The British Museum has some photos of the alleys around Cloth Fair taken in 1877 by A. Bool for the Society for Photographing Relics of Old London.  These photos (©Trustees of the British Museum) show ancient buildings crowded around narrow alleys.

Cloth Fair

The following photo shows not only the narrow alleys around Cloth Fair, but also how Cloth Fair has changed over the years. The photo shows a narrow alley. A small child is at the end of the alley and on the left are houses leaning over the alley to get a small bit of additional space for the upper floor.

Look to the right of the photo and there is a substantial stone building.

Cloth Fair

I found the above photos after I had walked along Cloth Fair, so I could not get a photo in the same position, however after looking again at my photos it was clear where the above photo was taken.

On the right in the above photo there are three arches at ground level. Above this, there is a roof, leading back to a higher stone wall with windows and drain pipes. Towards the end of the alley, the building on the right is higher still, with an angled roof.

Now look at the photo below and it is clear that the building on the right in the above photo is the side wall of the St. Bartholomew the Great.

Cloth Fair

The original photo was taken roughly were the furthest bollard is now located, looking towards the nearest bollard, which is roughly where the child was standing. Two of the three arches can be clearly seen, as can the roof above, the windows and drain pipes. Getting closer to the camera, the building rises a level with an angled roof, as in the original photo.

The houses on the left of the original photo were where the “Keep Clear” signs are on the road today. This alley was not Cloth Fair, but ran parallel to the church where Cloth Fair should have been, so how did this work?

Turning to the 1895 Ordinance Survey map provided the answer:

Cloth Fair

Cloth Fair can be seen running left to right across the map. Below Cloth Fair is St. Bartholomew the Great.

Look just above the church, and between the church and Cloth Fair, running half way along Cloth Fair is another row of houses with a narrow alley between the church and Cloth Fair. This is the alley in the photo.

The alley and houses have clearly disappeared since 1895, however that cannot be the full story otherwise there would be a much larger space today, where the alley, houses and Cloth Fair were located.

The extract from the map of the area today has the answer:

Cloth Fair

The angle of the route of Cloth Fair as it runs past the church to the right has been changed. In the 1895 map, the junction with Middle Street is slightly offset, today Cloth Fair runs straight into Middle Street. Cloth Fair today is also running parallel to the church.

The British Museum collection also has the following photo, which I believe is taken in the same alley, but this time looking in the opposite direction as to the photo above, now with the church of St. Bartholomew on the left of the photo. This is looking towards the where the alley exits onto Cloth Fair in the 1895 OS map.

Cloth Fair

In the photo below, the alley in the above two 1877 photos ran along the footpath on the left, and the majority of the road was occupied by the houses in the photo. The original Cloth Fair ran along the footpath and partly under the buildings on the right. In the above photo there is a building projecting out at the end of the low roof leading up from the bottom left of the photo. This is the entrance porch seen in the photo below with the black and white patterned roof.

Cloth Fair

So even along streets as old as Cloth Fair, we can never be sure we are actually walking along the route of the original street. Along this stretch of the street today we are walking along the old alley and where the houses once stood.

There are many other lovely buildings along Cloth Fair. This is the Rising Sun pub at Number 38.  A pub has been at this location for a number of centuries. I can find newspaper reports mentioning the pub going back to the start of the 19th century, and the pub is (although not the same building), much older.

Cloth Fair

Cloth Fair would have been risky place to be in during the Bartholomew Fair. The are numerous reports of crimes in the area, many violent and plenty of thefts, including the following from the Rising Sun:

“On Monday se’nnight, some thieves during the busy period of the evening, it being at the time of Bartholomew Fair, broke into the upper apartments of Mr William Sawyer, of the Rising Sun, Cloth Fair, and carried off all the wearing apparel, some sheets, and two watches, &c., to the value in the whole of £60 with which they decamped, and have not yet been discovered”.

This is number 43 Cloth Fair, also on Cloth Court,

Cloth Fair

The building was home to Sir John Betjeman from 1954 for 20 years. He moved into the building after meeting Paul Paget and John Seely and seeing their restoration work in Cloth Fair. The building is now owned by the Landmark Trust.

Cloth Fair

Although Cloth Fair has lost many of the alleys that lined and led off from the main street, there are still a few that remain to give a limited sense of what the area was once like.

Cloth Fair

The buildings that line Cloth Fair are fascinating, as is the history of the street and association with the Bartholomew Fair, however after finding the photos of the alleys and the alley that once ran along the edge of the church, it was being able to place the alley, and the realisation that streets I thought were original have slightly changed their route over the years that was really pleasing.

It is these little details that make walking London’s streets so interesting.

alondoninheritance.com

16 thoughts on “The Lost Alleys Of Cloth Fair

  1. Vicky

    I do love walking around the old parts of my London town. I was born in Enfield. The real suburbs. Not as many interesting places to wander. But i’ve been living in Covent Garden the last 10 years. A much more interesting place to let you feel the history of this fascinating city.

    Plus. I do love going to old pubs. Not these awful ‘ghastly gastro’ pubs. The Rising Sun you photographed is a lovely old Sam Smiths ‘boozer’. I love the Cheshire Cheese in Fleet St & the White Horse in Soho. It’s great that they still have this tradition going. Buy a cheap drink, a bag of crisps & you can sit & talk in an ‘inebriated’ fashion and think of all the other thousands of people who have sat in your chair before you!

    Reply
  2. Jane MacNamara

    Thank you for your interesting piece on Cloth Fair. It is a street that my distant cousin Alban Leaf would have known. Cousin Alban was a warehouseman who lived and worked in Bartholomew Close from about 1710 to 1756. I’d love to pin down the location. Any suggestions?

    Reply
    1. Annie G

      What a great name for an ancestor. Can I recommend the amazing site collage.cityoflondon.gov.uk as a place to find remarkable images of Bartholomew Close and a place to start your search. There is also an excellent resource called British History Online with a relevant document about the development of Bartholomew Close. Best of luck!

      Reply
  3. Scott

    I’ve said it before but need to say it again: thank you for your wonderful blog! It’s always fascinating and a pleasure to read!

    Reply
  4. Joseph Pigg

    Brilliant piece of City history! I came to work in Smithfield 1963 and have a long association with this area ever since. My daughter now works in Long Lane and has inherited my interest in this historical area.
    Keep up the good work!

    Reply
  5. Geraldine Moyle

    What a wonderful bit of sleuthing, David. You are a magician with maps!

    In your photo of the corner of Cloth Fair & Cloth Court, I hope I see that the bricked up window with “The Sailor’s Home Coming” is still there. Another reason to be grateful to Seely & Paget.

    Reply
  6. Jools

    A lovely corner of London not often seen, I joined Midland Bank West Smithfield in 1976 (now I believe a bar – The Meat and Cleaver) and many a lunch hour was spend either in the Barley Mow or the Hand and Shears, then later the Rising Sun after it had reopened. The Barley Mow was known as our “sub branch” and customers would often look for us there. I love the architecture around there and was always told to look up and not just eye level as the buildings sometimes had more to offer up high. Thank you for such great pictures.

    Reply
  7. Kathleen Munden

    Love this one! Cloth Fair is my favorite place in London. I have stayed in both of the Landmark Trust properties (45a and 43 Cloth Fair), and highly recommend them. Visit the Landmark Trust website for pictures of the interior and some additional history. Both look over the churchyard of St. Bart’s, and Smithfield Market is just around the corner. In the evenings and on weekends, it is very quiet, and sitting in the churchyard or walking through the alleys is very eerie. It truly feels as though one has gone back in time by several centuries.

    Reply
  8. psl

    once again such an interesting report, you are blessed with your fathers photos, what a piece of modern history! I will call into Cloth Fair when I next visit London. many thanks

    Reply
  9. Annie G

    This was great. The missing houses that were removed at the beginning of the 20th century have long been something I have wished to see for myself. A shame they were not retained and restored.

    Reply
  10. Ron Curwood

    Thank you for the details of Cloth Fair.
    According the the 1851 Census No. 37 Cloth Fair was the home of my great great grandfather Herbert Davies and his family.
    It is interesting to discover from your article what is was like about that time, it would appear a tough place to live. So different to here in New Zealand.

    Ron Curwood

    Reply
  11. Endymion

    This is an outstanding piece and I thank you for it. Some years ago I spent about three weeks in Barts Hospital undergoing high-dose chemotherapy treatment so all the buildings, the surrounding streets and alleyways hold such intense memories for me – initially of fear and despair but ultimately of hope and health (I’m still here!). The area has an often very dark and cruel history but as your blog shows there are fascinating points of interest at every turn. All your pieces are totally absorbing.

    Reply
  12. Peter Holford

    A corner of London I never knew existed – I seem to have walked all around it over the years. Excellent forensic work with photos and maps as usual – always gets my interest.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Peter Holford Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *