A brief post this week as I have been short of time, however a post that covers two aspects of London that fascinate me. The first is about London’s buildings, the considerable range of different architectural styles over the centuries, how these change, how some buildings survive, the degree of rapid change – Fountain House in Fenchurch Street is a good example.
The second aspect are the traces of London’s history that can still be found in a rapidly changing City, and for this, St Gabriel, Fenchurch is an example.
Fountain House, Fenchurch Street
I came across Fountain House whilst walking along Fenchurch Street. There is nothing special about the building, however the design of Fountain House is from a specific period. It is the type of building that I expect will soon disappear and be replaced by a much taller glass and steel tower, making full use of the space not occupied by the relatively thin tower.
This is the view approaching Fountain House from the east, along Fenchurch Street:
Fountain House was constructed between 1954 and 1958 to a design by W.H.Rogers and Sir Howard Robertson (Consulting). It was the first London building constructed to the tower and podium formula where a large podium occupies the full area of the plot of land, with a much small central space occupied by a tower block.
The lower podium block is occupied by a central entrance foyer and around the street level of the podium there is space for a range of retail units.
The corners of the podium are almost triangular in shape to fit within the surrounding streets. As the central tower only occupies a small percentage of the overall plot of land, today’s developers would no doubt consider this to be wasted space and a modern replacement would see a glass and steel tower occupying the full width and depth of the land available.
This is the view of the corner of the podium, which faces to the east. The clock makes a good central feature to the corner of the building.
A walk down Mincing Lane provides a view of the width of the tower to the street, only three bays wide.
The Pevsner guide describes Fountain House as:
“The first office tower in London to repeat the motif of Gordon Bunshaft’s Lever House, New York (1952), that is a low horizontal block with a tall tower above, here set end-on to the street. With its podium curving to the street and lower return wing along Cullum Street, the composition is tentative compared with later versions of the formula.”
The Lever House in New York, referred to by Pevsner is shown in the photo below. The same concept of podium and tower that would be repeated a couple of years after Lever House was built in 1952 in the City of London with Fountain House.
In the late 1950s, Fountain House must have appeared to be the latest architectural style transferring from New York – the City of London rising from the destruction of the war.
Fountain House in the final stages of completion in 1957:
Image credit: London Metropolitan Archives, City of London: catalogue ref: SC_PHL_01_010_57_3038
The central entrance to Fountain House:
The two pillars can be seen in the 1957 photo, however I suspect the canopy was a later addition.
A look into the entrance foyer reveals what looks to be a refurbished interior:
The corner of the podium on the western edge of Fountain House:
Always on the look out for plaques attached to buildings, I found the following fixed to Fountain House along the side of the building facing onto Fen Court. The plaque from December 1964 marks the boundary of the site with the implication that the land belongs to the Clothworkers Company (who have their Hall just to the south of Fountain House).
The Clothworkers Company do indeed still own the freehold to Fountain House.
So what is the future for Fountain House?
This first example of podium and tower architecture in the City of London may not be around for too much longer. A development agreement is in place between the Clothworkers Company and the tenant of the building for a major redevelopment of the site. Fountain House will be replaced by a new block which occupies the whole site and makes use of the empty space above the podium, not occupied by the tower. The new building looks to be very much like any other glass and steel tower to be found across the City.
The tenant can commence development from 2017, so I suspect this will happen when the financial case for a new office block makes sense to the tenant.
A shame as I rather like Fountain House.
St Gabriel Fenchurch
The following photo is the view looking east along Fenchurch Street. Fountain House is the building on the left.
Look to the right of the photo and there is a blue plaque.
This records that the church of St Gabriel Fenchurch stood in the roadway opposite, so would have been in the centre of the photo above.
St Gabriel Fenchurch was one of the many City churches destroyed in the Great Fire of 1666 and not rebuilt.
I have not been able to find too much about the church. There are no prints of the church in my books on London churches and history or online (that I could find).
There is a brief description of the church in “London churches before the Great Fire” by Wilberforce Jenkinson published in 1917:
“The church of S. Gabriel, Fenchurch Street, formerly stood in the middle of the street, and was built not later than the fourteenth century. Before 1517 it was known as S. Mary’s and some time ‘All Saints’. Possibly there was a triple dedication. Corruptly it went by the name of Fen Church and gave a name to the street. The district may have been marshy, for the brook, the Langbourne, went through it, and Langbourne Ward is still in evidence. The first rector was John Payne. 1321. The church was a small one, but was enlarged in 1631. In the Return made in 1636 the income of the rectory, including the house, was stated to be £131.
This house, with the garden and graveyard, was the gift of H. Legges. R.Cook, who was rector during the Civil War, was ejected for his loyalty in 1642, but was reinstated at the Restoration.
The church figured in the City decorations on the day of King James I’s coronation entertainment. Ben Jonson described it in 1603:
At Fen-Church the scene presented itself in a square and flat upright, like to the side of a Citie; the top thereof, above the Vent and Crest adorned with houses, towres and steeples in prospective.”
Stowe in his Survey of London has but a single sentence for the church: “In the midst of this streete standeth a small parish Church called S. Gabriel Fenchurch, corruptly Fan church.”
Much the same description is given in the 1771 edition of Chamberlain’s Survey of London, so all the descriptions of St Gabriel’s provide a consistent view of the church.
The Collage archive at the London Metropolitan Archives has a map which shows the location of the church in the centre of Fenchurch Street. The strange thing about this map is that Collage dates the map as c1800 which is 134 years after the church was destroyed in the Great Fire.
Image credit: London Metropolitan Archives, City of London: catalogue ref: k1264238
The map shows the position of the church, and also the burial ground of St Gabriel, part of which can still be found today.
Fen Court is shown on the map leading from Fenchurch Street to the burial ground. I mentioned Fen Court earlier in the post, and it still runs from Fenchurch Street along the eastern edge of Fountain House, to where the remains of the burial ground can be found.
Although St Gabriel Fenchurch was not rebuilt after the fire, the burial ground continued in use. A plaque records what happened:
The text is not that clear so is reproduced below:
“This churchyard was attached to the church of St Gabriel Fenchurch which was destroyed in the Great Fire of 1666. The parish was united with that of St Margaret Pattens in 1670 and was included in that of St Edmund Lombard Street in 1954. The churchyard was paved and planted by some of the owners and occupiers of the adjoining buildings in 1960.”
The text illustrates how churchyards and burial grounds from churches not rebuilt would be taken up by other local churches. This contributed significantly to the long term survival of these patches of land in a City ever hungry for additional growth space.
The remaining graves appear to be from the 18th and 19th century. Nothing from the time of St Gabriel which is not a surprise, and I suspect burials ended in the 19th century as happened across the majority of City burial grounds and churchyards as after centuries of taking the dead of the City of London, they were over full and a serious health hazard to an expanding City.
A rather ornately carved grave remains:
Which appears to have been built in 1762 by Anne Cotesworth as a burying place for herself as she was born in the parish and her nearest relations were buried in the next vault.
The remains of the burial ground of St Gabriel Fenchurch are immediately behind Fountain House. Hopefully this reminder of a long lost church will not be impacted by any redevelopment.
Fountain House is a reminder of how architectural styles change so quickly across London. Once the first example of a new design imported from New York. Sixty years later, and it may well be disappearing in the next few years – and London continues to evolve.
I have long thought that buildings of the podium/tower design (like your example) retained a certain style, maybe even an elegance.
However, because they usually tend to be from an era when build quality and materials were not as effective as in later times, as a Property Manager/Maintainer I normally found them a nightmare!
Thanks for this piece. As Fountain House is a rarity & quite an early one, is there no chance of having it listed? After all, No. 1 Poultry is said to have been listed & that is controversial! I like this design with it’s single storey st of shops with clock topped by a narrow office bloack.
I totally agree with the fact that it should be listed. It’s design is very pleasing to the eye and uniquely stands out among the other buildings in the surrounding area. It definitely has character.
Another great post, Thank you
I live on a podium-tower estate in the City and from a residential point of view it works very well. Visitors are amazed at what we have and at the whole concept; I often take people round. At podium level we have a large private garden, amazing for an estate in central London.
Wow, that sounds amazing. I know a lot of the City but can’t think where this would be.
It’s the Middlesex Street Estate, not far from Liverpool Street Station.
Thank you, all interesting and of great value to know …
Another fascinating article, thank you. As always, it is a reminder that the history of London is both up above the shops and down beneath our feet, in the form of ancient burial grounds.
What an interesting post! Such a shame about Fountain House though – it seems like there should be a way to renovate it so that it doesn’t lose its unique and historic style. At this rate, there won’t be much of historic London left, which is sad because I think that’s what makes the city so interesting. As you say – hopefully the plaque to that church will stay untouched because it adds a lot of character to this area.
Thanks for the post about St. Gabriel Fenchurch and the pictures of the site present day.
I don’t know if anyone can help here please. I am trying to find out what happened to The Fountain which was commissioned to be installed in Fountain House 130 Fenchurch Street in 1957 but has disappeared from the building. Margaret J Wrightson was the sculptor. It was quite a size. It consisted of a youth (my husband was used as model) holding a ship and an aeroplane in either hand – symbols of the old and the new. Water poured from under the globe which was upheld by four sea horses. The water fell first into shells and overflowed into the main basin. On the rim of the basin were two dolphins which spouted water. At the side of the rim were two eagles facing the globe more description. Behind the whole fountain was a sheet of glass over which the water continually flowed. Boy in aluminium rest cast in bronze. Any help regarding this appreciated. Where did it go, when was it removed? Morris Singer who were at Winchester at the time,executed the work for Margaret Wrightson and still have drawings for the commission. A mystery. I think it was about 14’ in height so not small by any means. I do have a photo.
As the sculpture was already in Fountain House maybe it would be a good idea to contact the owner or managing agent of the building and go from there. I am more than happy to enquire for you if you wish since I’ve been making similar enquiries re Plantation House which used to be across the road from Fountain House as my father had a business there and I’d like to have a plaque placed there as a commemoration to him. I believe there are plans to redevelop the site of Fountain House so it would be best to act sooner rather than later.
I can be reached by email: email@example.com
Mobile: 07526-951891 if you would like to speak and discuss further.